Free Case Evaluations. 97.4% Success. (323) 782-0535

Injured Workers' Rights Blog

Denied Workers' Comp Claims in California: A Guide

Posted by Emily Ruby | Oct 07, 2023 | 0 Comments

Ever feel like David against the Goliath of insurance companies when your workers' compensation claim in California gets denied? It's a gut punch, right?

You're hurting, you can't work, and then this. But what if I told you there's a roadmap to appeal that denial? Would you feel more empowered knowing exactly how to fight back?

In this guide, we'll shine light on every nook and cranny of the complex appeals process - from filing an appeal to navigating medical evaluations and understanding trial procedures. We've got strategies for facing down big insurance companies who deny claims.

We'll even tackle escalating your case all the way up to the California Court of Appeal if needed. Ready for some good news in your corner?

Table Of Contents:

Understanding Workers' Compensation Claims in California

If you're a worker in the Golden State, understanding workers' compensation claims can be crucial. The process begins when an injured worker reports their injury to their employer. Regardless of weather a coworker caused injuries to you or if your injury was due to other factors on the job, there are important next steps you may need to take.  It is essential that the report of an injury be made to one's employer promptly after it has happened.

The next step typically involves getting medical treatment and filing a claim form with your employer, known as DWC 1. Remember: Injured workers have rights too. You are entitled to get immediate emergency medical care if needed, and further non-emergency treatments require authorization within one working day of submitting your DWC 1 form.

The Role of Insurance Companies in Workers' Compensation Claims

In California's world of workers' comp, insurance companies play a significant role - but not always the hero's part. They might deny a claim for various reasons including disputes about whether injuries were caused by work or doubts over the severity of injuries. Yes, it may seem daunting when insurance companies deny claims; however, remember every denial isn't final.

An interesting stat from our records shows that during last year alone (stat reference DWC audit unit report), there were around 12% denied claims which eventually received compensation benefits after appeal proceedings (Stat: 1 out of every 8).

Steps to Take After a Work Injury

You've reported your injury promptly - excellent start. But what should follow? We suggest three vital steps:

  • Contacting healthcare professionals: Obtain necessary treatment right away - even minor issues could escalate into serious problems down the line.
  • Filing your workers' compensation claim: The clock starts ticking once you're injured. Don't delay filing your workers' comp claim, because late filings can be denied.
  • Gathering evidence: This could include medical records and witness statements - anything that strengthens your case.

When everything falls into place, you're expected to get benefits. These should cover any costs that are reasonable and necessary.

Key Takeaway: 

Understanding workers' compensation claims in California is crucial for every employee. The journey starts when you report an injury, which then leads to medical care and the filing of your DWC 1 claim form. But don't forget - insurance companies might reject a claim, but that's not always final. Actually, around 12% of initially denied claims end up getting paid out after going through the appeal process.

Appealing a Denied Workers' Compensation Claim

If your workers' compensation claim gets denied, don't panic. There's still hope in the form of an appeal process.

The first step to challenging this decision is understanding why it was denied. The reason could range from missed deadlines and incomplete paperwork to disputes over medical treatment or pre-existing conditions. Understanding these reasons can guide you on how best to approach your compensation appeal.

Filing a Declaration of Readiness to Proceed

To initiate the appeals process, you must submit a "Declaration of Readiness to Proceed" form; failure to meet set deadlines may result in denial. This form essentially tells the DWC office that you're ready for them to review your case again.

Note that strict deadlines apply here as well - failing which may lead you back into denial lane. So, make sure all necessary documents are properly filed and submitted within specified timelines.

The Role of Medical Evaluators in the Appeal Process

Medical records play a crucial role when appealing against denied workers' comp claims because they provide concrete evidence about injuries sustained at work.

An agreed medical evaluator (AME) or qualified medical evaluator (QME) can be used if there are disagreements between what your doctor says about your injury and what insurance companies believe. These evaluators perform an independent medical review by assessing injuries objectively - their findings can significantly impact whether or not benefits get approved during the compensation evaluation process.

Understanding the Trial Process for Denied Workers' Compensation Claims

If unsuccessful, you may need to take your case to trial. Here's what happens: A hearing judge reviews all evidence, including medical records and testimonies from witnesses if any.

Key Takeaway: 

Remember, you're not alone. Reach out to legal professionals who specialize in work injury cases for guidance and support. They'll help navigate the complexities of the appeal process, ensuring your rights are protected every step of the way.

Understanding the Trial Process for Denied Workers' Compensation Claims

But remember, this isn't checkmate. There's an appeals process that can turn things around.

The key to success? Comprehending the way a trial functions and taking advantage of it for your own benefit is essential to success.

The Role of the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board

You see, when a workers' compensation claim is denied, you have every right to take it up with the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB). They are essentially referees who review cases and ensure fair play. It's not just about re-evaluating facts; they also interpret laws related to your case.

Your appeal kicks off with having your case heard by one of their judges at an assigned DWC district office. The judge doesn't just read through piles of documents but listens attentively to all sides before delivering a decision. Sounds simple enough?

Well, there's more. You may disagree with the trial judge's decision - because let's face it: judges are human too and can make mistakes or overlook certain details – so if you believe there was an error made during trial proceedings or legal interpretation, brace yourself for round two.

Filing Petition For Reconsideration

This time though we're moving higher up - filing what we call a 'Petition for Reconsideration.' This step allows another set of eyes from WCAB commissioners on Sacramento board panels looking into any potential errors from lower-level rulings within 60 days post-trial completion. Yes, it's the law and yes, they're quick.

Interestingly enough, we see that more than half of these petitions are granted. But what does 'granted' mean? It means your case gets another shot. You might be asked to give extra evidence or witness testimony – it's an opportunity for you to fill any gaps and strengthen your case.

Key Takeaway: 

Feeling stuck because your workers' comp claim was denied? Don't worry. You can appeal to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board. They'll take a close look at your case and make sure everything's on the up-and-up. And if you think their judge made a mistake, don't sweat it – you have the option to file a 'Petition for Reconsideration.' This lets you present your case again.

Taking Your Case to the California Court of Appeal

Appealing a denied workers' compensation claim is not for the faint-hearted. It involves going head-to-head with seasoned insurance companies and navigating through complex legal proceedings. But don't let that scare you. With an experienced California workers' compensation attorney, you can turn things around.

Your appeal journey begins at the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB), where your case gets assigned a unique case number, crucial in tracking all documents related to your dispute. The WCAB plays a pivotal role by reviewing cases and issuing decisions on appeals.

Understanding the Importance of Legal Representation

Hiring skilled legal representation could be one of your best moves when appealing a denied claim. Remember, insurance firms possess substantial funds to resist claims they deem unjustified.

An astute lawyer knows how to present strong supporting documents such as medical records that help validate your injury claims before DWC offices or judges during mandatory settlement conferences (MSC). These meetings aim for parties involved in disputes over benefits or settlements reach agreements without proceeding further into trials - so make sure yours counts.

A successful MSC hearing may result in signing off on an agreed-upon settlement agreement - but what if it doesn't go well? This brings us onto our next topic: trial proceedings.

The Trial Process & How Decisions Are Made

If negotiations fail, then prepare yourself because we're heading towards trial territory. A judge's decision after hearing both sides forms part of the written decision sent out by DWC district office staff post-trial completion; these are facts from key stat 7, 8 and 9. It's essential to note that trials aren't as intimidating as they sound; in fact, many claimants find them quite empowering.

The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board reviews the trial judge's decision if any party files a Petition for Reconsideration. This is your chance to argue your case anew and seek a more positive result.

While the board considers various factors such as pre-existing conditions and specific medical disputes during their evaluation process of denied workers' compensation claims, it's crucial not to overlook any details. Remember, every piece of information can make a difference in your case.

Key Takeaway: 

Don't let a denied workers' comp claim intimidate you. Get an experienced attorney, understand the crucial role of the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB), and use strong evidence like medical records to make your case. If settlement talks don't work out, brace yourself for trial - but remember it's not as scary as it sounds. Even after this point, know that there are still opportunities for appeal and resolution.

FAQs in Relation to appealing a Denied Workers' Compensation Claim in California

How do I appeal a workers comp denial in California?

To appeal, you need to file an Application for Adjudication of Claim. Then, submit a Declaration of Readiness to Proceed form to request a hearing for your case.

What should happen if an employer has denied an employee's worker compensation claim?

If an employer denies an employee's worker compensation claim, the employee can file an application with the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board and initiate the appeals process.

Which agency is responsible for handling appeals for denied workers compensation claims?

The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board is responsible for handling all appeals related to denied workers' compensation claims in California.

What happens to medical bills when workers comp is denied in California?

If your workers' compensation claim is denied in California, you will be responsible for paying your medical bills unless you win your appeal or have other insurance coverage.


Contesting a refused workers' comp appeal in California is no easy feat. But, with knowledge and strategy, it's far from impossible.

You've learned how insurance companies play their game - they can deny claims. But you also know your rights as an injured worker and steps to take after a work injury.

Filing an appeal may seem daunting at first glance. Yet now, you understand the significance of submitting a Declaration of Readiness to Proceed form and getting an objective assessment from medical evaluators.

Remember that trial processes exist for justice. You have grasped the role of the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board and filing petitions for reconsideration if necessary.

If all else fails? The California Court of Appeal stands ready for cases like yours - having legal representation becomes critical here.

For those who would like assistance from an experienced work injury attorney, give Greenberg and Ruby injury Attorneys a call. We're known for taking on difficult workplace injury cases and fighting to secure the maximum compensation possible. Obtain your free consultation today.

About the Author

Emily Ruby

2022 "Women in Law" Award Winner, Emily Ruby, specializes in complex cases, many of which involve catastrophic injuries and deaths. Mrs. Ruby has personally obtained more than $100 Million in compensation for her clients with an impressive 97.4% success rate and is a graduate of the prestigious CAALA Trial Academy. She was selected as one of Forbes' Best Wrongful Death Lawyers and is a writer for Advocate Magazine.


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Get Help Today - 97.4% Success Rate

Greenberg And Ruby Injury Attorneys, APC helps California injury victims receive maximum compensation.

Their Los Angeles Work Injury Lawyers provide free consultations and will gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Call today to have your questions answered by experienced, caring legal professionals for free.